21 Amazon Fashion Items in NYC Girls' Carts
New York City women know good style. That's purely a fact we've come to accept. Maybe it's the perpetually unknown weather or the fact that walking everywhere is inevitable, but the East Coast city is filled with so many stylish residents that we can't help but be curious about things like their key wardrobe essentials and what they're shopping for this fall.
Our curiosity goes so far as to lead us to another shopping destination we all shamelessly shop: Amazon's fashion section. We asked a few of our favorite NYC girls to share the items that can be regularly found in their Amazon shopping carts. From the perfect workout pieces to the most eye-catching accessories, their buys are equally as stylish as they are (not that we're surprised). Keep reading to find out about their must-have Amazon items, and then shop their picks.
"I love Penny's boutique for the velvet scrunchies. I have them in almost every color and print, but special favorites of mine are the animal prints like leopard and zebra. Also, these Maribou heels—they're the perfect height for a klutz like me. Ellie's also has some serious six-inch stompers, but I can't deejay or run down my five-flight walk-up in those, so this is a great compromise." — Amrit Sidhu
"I never thought I'd say it, but I'm really loving bike shorts at the moment—for the summer, they've pretty much replaced all my leggings for workouts, errand-running, etc. These look super sleek and supportive with the high-waist cut, and they're under $20. It's a win all around." — Gina Marinelli
"A few pieces I look for on Amazon are bathing suits. Surprisingly, they have some great bathing suits for amazing prices. Also they have really cute sunglasses, like the cute vintage ones with the small lenses. And lastly, I search for nylon track pants on the site. They have tons of Nike track pants. With fall right around the corner, I'll be stocking up on them soon." — Danielle Leguillou
"I love to update my denim for each season, and there's no easier way than through Amazon. I'll be adding at least a new pair of jeans and a jean jacket to my wardrobe very soon." — Nicole Akhtarzad
"I love Amazon for fun inexpensive accessories. I usually go for the crazier 'trend' pieces that I want to have fun with but don't want to invest in. I love these colorful glasses. Cool for a look and for $13, I can get all the colors." — Kellie Brown
"I recently cut my hair and have no idea what to do with it. Since I'm running around all day in the city and rarely have time to stop home, I've been wanting something to put in my hair when the day has essentially worn it down. These cute rhinestone barrettes will do just the trick." — Lauren Eggertsen
"I love ordering Hanes white tank tops in a multi-pack on Amazon. It's so easy to just click, and I know a size small fits. They're the best basics—so good alone in the summer, or layered under a sweater in the winter. Honestly too good to be true." — Bianca Valle
For even more affordable finds, shop the 21 "cheap thrills" I'm buying for a quick wardrobe refresh.
Anna is an NYC-based senior fashion editor who has been a member of theBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing team for over seven years, having begun her career in L.A. at brands like Michael Kors and A.L.C. As an editor, she has earned a reputation for her coverage of breaking trends, emerging brands, luxury shopping curations, fashion features, and more. Anna has penned a numberBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing cover interviews, including Megan Fox, Julia Garner, and Lilly Collins. She also leads the site’s emerging travel vertical that highlights all things travel and lifestyle through a fashion-person lens.
-
35 Incredibly Chic Finds From All of the Best Presidents' Day Sales Worth Shopping
Don't miss out.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
I Forgot About These Winter Boots Until Meghan Markle Styled a Pair In the Most 2025 Way
Good thing they're on sale.
By Eliza Huber
-
If a Parisian and New Yorker Shopped theReplica Store Winter Sale, They'd Like These 38 Pieces
The chicest picks.
By Bobby Schuessler
-
5 Commute-Friendly Trends I'm Buying to Wear in NYC This Year
What to wear when you've got places to be.
By Natalie Cantell
-
I Just Relocated From Berlin to NYC—These 7 Items Are Already Becoming Staples
Hardworking items.
By Anna LaPlaca
-
I Live in Brooklyn and Am Sure This Is the Only Coat Trend New Yorkers Will Wear Until Spring
I see it everywhere I go.
By Natalie Cantell
-
I'm a New Yorker—5 Fresh and Elegant Micro-Trends Everyone's Suddenly Wearing
Easy, in-the-know outfit tweaks (that don't cost a million dollars).
By Natalie Cantell
-
The Specific Color Combo That's Bubbling Up in NYC Right Now
Chic.
By Drew Elovitz