J.Lo! Hailey! Katie! The "Ugly" Sandals Celebs and French Girls Have Firmly Agree On

Over the past few seasons, we have seen a shift towards practicality in fashion, and this is seen most acutely with footwear. We need our shoes to be able to take us on countless laps of the park without causing us any trouble, so high heels have been universally retired. Fashion brands have been bringing us sturdy, responsible shoes for several seasons—the kind of styles you'd try to run away from when finding shoes at Clarks in sixth grade. Think T-bar loafers, chunky lace-ups, and fisherman sandals.
The Row and Gabriella Hearst both are adored for their discreet and quiet take on luxury fashion, and although both tend to shy away from anything too flashy or trend-driven, they both have a habit of dictating the silhouettes that we'll be gravitating towards. Both have created beautiful caged leather sandals in both ivory and black, making the humble fisherman sandal the most sought-after sandal for 2025. Like Tevas, their appeal is that they are practical walking shoes and will go with almost any outfit. Keep scrolling for proof that they really do look amazing with all looks, and then shop our edit of the best pairs.
The Best Fisherman Sandals, At a Glance
- The Best Designer Sandals: The Row Fisherman Flat Leather Sandals
- The Best White Sandals: Reformation Freya Fisherman Sandals
- The Best Splurge Sandals: Miu Miu Leather Fisherman Sandals
- The Best Black Sandals: Saint G Neive Fisherman Sandals
- The Best Budget-Friendly Sandals: Comfortview Fisherman Sandals
Best Designer Sandals
The fashion industry continues to be obsessed with The Row.
Size range: 6 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Two
Best Platform Sandals
These classic sandals come in seven colors.
Size range: 5.5 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Seven
These are bound to sell out.
Size range: 5 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Two
Best Lightweight Sandals
Melissa always comes through with great prices.
Size range: 5 to 10
Material: PVC
Colors: Seven
Chunky soles never fail.
Size range: 6 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Two
I love this pair.
Size range: 6 to 11
Material: Calf leather
Colors: Two
Best Modern Sandals
Don't these look so chic? You also have to see the tan suede iteration.
Size range: 5 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Two
Miu Miu has never failed me in the sandal department.
Size range: 5 to 10
Material: Calfskin leather
Colors: One
Try out the heel version if you dare.
Size range: 5 to 11
Material: Pigskin leather
Colors: One
How can I possibly choose a favorite? These come in three colorways.
Size range: 7.5 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Three
These are so cute.
Size range: 6 to 11
Material: Rubber
Colors: One
So classic.
Size range: 6 to 12
Material: Leather
Colors: One
These have the luxe look at a quarter of the price.
Size range: 5 to 11
Material: Suede
Colors: One
The kind of shoes that will last you decades.
Size range: 6 to 12
Material: Leather
Colors: Two
The Spain-based footwear and handbag brand, Hereu, is known for its classic designs with a modern edge.
Size range: 6 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: One
Best Chunky Fisherman Sandals
These are begging to be worn with a white dress.
Size range: 5 to 11
Material: Leather
Colors: Three
This story was originally published at an earlier date and has since been updated.

Emma is a freelance fashion editor with over 15 years experience in industry, having worked at The Telegraph, Grazia and, most recently, British Vogue. Emma was part of the founding team of Who What Wear UK, where she worked for six years as Deputy Editor and then Editor—helping shape the team into what it is today is one of the biggest privileges of her career and she will always see herself as aBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing girl, contributing to both the US and UK sites. Whether she's writing about runway trends or spotlighting emerging brands, she aims to write about fashion in a way that is democratic and doesn't promote over consumption.
-
This Elevated Basics Brand Is Every NYC and London Fashion Person's Best-Kept Secret
And I just tried on nine pieces in its NYC pop-up.
By Eliza Huber
-
Chic Shopping Lists Are My Thing—31 Great Finds FromReplica Store, Zara, Banana Republic, Shopbop, and Ref
Jackets, dresses, flats, and more!
By Bobby Schuessler
-
I'm a Fashion Editor Who Loves Effortless Vacation Essentials—25 Gap Finds That Caught My Eye
Many are even on major sale.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
If The Row, Khaite, and Toteme Feel Too Expensive, Here Are 33 Pieces to Try Instead
Bring on the luxe-looking outfits.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
This Is How All the Cool L.A. Girls Will Wear Summer's Biggest Sandal Trend
Guess it's time to order a pair.
By Allyson Payer
-
9 Top, Jeans, and Shoe Outfit Combos That Fashion People Will Be Wearing This Spring
I plan to re-create these ASAP.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
These $30 Gap Sandals Are Just as Cool as the $650 Pair That's Been on My Mind Since Last Spring
They are currently on sale for just $17.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
The $50Replica Store Shoes I'm Buying to Mimic Hailey Bieber's Summery Toteme Look
The resemblance is uncanny.
By Nikki Chwatt
-
10 Spring Outfit Ideas That Will Make Anyone Look Like a Fashion Person
Bring on the compliments.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
Katie Holmes's New Sandals Are Causing Controversy on Reddit Right Now
Here's why.
By Drew Elovitz