I Live in NYC and See These 5 Specific Shoe Trends Everywhere I Look

Fashion influencer Michelle Li wearing a blue summer dress and flat boots in New York City.

(Image credit: @himichelleli)

There's not a lot of time for BS when it comes to footwear in New York City. People are bizzay. They're walking here! There are cobblestone streets and subway steps to contend with, not to mention those super-steep, death-trap stairs at Prada's Mercer Street entrance. Work boots and competitive athleticwear aside, footwear on the streets of NYC has to work harder than just about anywhere else, so if a shoe or sandal trend is trending here, it feels like it's really earned it.

I truly love peeping what's going on below the ankles of people in the city. It's where my eyes wander any time I'm waiting at a street corner, sitting on the L, or sitting at an outside table at Casetta or anywhere else with great foot traffic. I'm always on the lookout for what's trending in this fair city and love to talk about it, so humor me by letting me chat you through the five great footwear moments that are dominating the streets right now.

Minimalistic Sandals

Fashion influencer and interior stylist Madelynn Hudson wears minimalistic black sandals in New York City with a white eyelet tank and matching shorts from Doen and a black leather handbag.

(Image credit: @madelynnhudson)

More than any other style, I'm noticing super-minimal, flat sandals in classic black and brown, from trending leather toe loops to… What's the opposite of a toe loop? (See the Tkees style below—it's hard to explain!)

Knee-High Boots

Fashion influencer Michelle Li wearing a blue summer dress and flat boots in New York City.

(Image credit: @himichelleli)

The closer I get to Dimes Square, the more I'm seeing boots teamed with breezy sundresses. It's a very specific downtown vibe—extremely cool, a little romantic, and perfect for people who have to GSD (get shit done) around the city on a Saturday when it's 90° before settling down at Le Dive for an orange wine.

Red Styles

Model and fashion influencer Amy Julliette Lefévre on the street in New York City with yellow cabs in the background wearing a white summer dress and bright red flat shoes.

(Image credit: @lefevrediary)

I love the way New Yorkers have collectively decided that the red trend has staying power. From flip-flops to strappy heels to mesh flats, the vibe is that this is still what we're adding to low-key, neutral outfits to let the world know we're not totally asleep at the wheel.

Two-Tone Flats

Fashion influencer and model Christie Tyler on the street in New York City with her hair slicked back in a low bun wearing two-tone Ferragamo ballet flats, a short skirt and carrying a large raffia bag.

(Image credit: @christietyler)

Two-tone Mary Janes and ballet flats really are everywhere I look right now, giving a preppy little something to outfits from SoHo to the UES. Slingback versions feel the coolest, in my humble opinion, especially when you get into iterations like Alexandre Birman's metallic toe-capped suede style below.

Jelly Sandals

Courtney Grow in NYC wearing blue jelly flats by The Row with white shorts, a white tee, and a black blazer.

(Image credit: @courtneygrow)

It just wouldn't be summer without some kind of footwear from The Row going viral, and Wholesale Replica Bag style to do so is the jelly Mara flats. Originally recognizable from The Row's pre-fall runway last September, the sold-out style is now usually seen peeping out from below tables at Gem Wine. Love 'em or hate 'em, jellies are a force to be reckoned with, from rubber flip-flops to fisherman sandals to perforated flats.

Natalie Cantell
Contributing Fashion Editor

Natalie Cantell is an NYC-based style director, creative consultant, and contributing fashion editor. She was the executive director of Who What Wear and Marie Claire’s brand studio until 2023, and now freelances globally on shoots, stories, and special projects across fashion, luxury, beauty, home, and travel.