5 Telltale Signs of Cheap Boots
If Carrie Bradshaw was our IRL friend in 2018, we imagine most of our conversations would revolve around how much debt she’s in thanks to her shoe obsession. Simply put: Shoes are expensive, and for many, they’re the priciest category in our closets. So while we couldn’t necessarily discourage you (or Carrie) from snapping up a great pair of boots this fall, we do want to focus on pairs that are worth your money. So how do we know we’re buying quality boots? We called in an expert…
Susanne Botschen, co-founder of massive luxury e-commerce site MyTheresa, is also the co-founder of MarthaLouisa.com. Launched earlier this year, MarthaLouisa.com is the website you’d expect to find right at the top of Carrie’s bookmark bar; it houses some of the coolest designer shoes available today. Suffice it to say: Botschen knows how to spot a quality pair of boots. And in an effort to share her expertise, she boiled it down to five easy—and critical—steps for how to do it yourself. Read on for Botschen’s five key telltale signs of a cheap pair of boots.
Mind the Bend
“A very important indicator is that the sole does not bend forward; that’s always a sign of poor quality.”
Not So Rough Around the Edges
“Rough visible seams, possibly irregular or thickened, are a no-go.”
In the Fold
“Patent leather quality problems are easy to detect, as you see them at first sight—for example, if the material shows wrinkles, or looks curly and creased after bending.”
Take Practice Steps
“When the form is too wide, the boot goes out of shape with every step. Take some steps on the clean carpet, and if you see that the middle part of the shoe is losing its form while walking, you better not buy those boots!”
Smooth Moves
“Last but not least, have a look at the zippers. They need to run smoothly.”
Shop Quality Boots for Fall
Haven't had your fill of fall boots? See the five boots trends are currently selling best, straight from Instagram.

Who's your style icon?
Taylor Tomasi Hill
Who are your 5 favorite people to follow on Twitter/Instagram?
@tamumcpherson @lisasaysgah @therealgracecoddington @everyoutfitonsatc @notmynonni
What's the fashion essential you can’t live without?
A leather jacket.
What's your desert island album?
Beyoncé "B'Day." Or pretty much anything Beyoncé.
-
My Honest Take on the Winter It Boots Every Fashion Person Is Talking AboutFrom Khaite to Free People.
-
Of All Her Outfits, *This* Hailey Bieber Look Is Stuck in My BrainAnd I will be re-creating it.
-
Just so You Know, Zara Already Has All the Best Shoes for Winter 2025Shop before they sell out.
-
Cool Sneakers, Flats, and Boots Are the Vibe—These 36 Styles Are Heavily Discounted for Black FridayEverything from Khaite to Ref to Adidas is at least 25% off.
-
If You're Going to Wear a Dress With Ankle Boots, This Is the Trend That Looks the Least DatedPSA via Suki Waterhouse.
-
Hilary Duff Knows the Smartest Boot Trend to Pair With Barrel JeansWhy didn't I think of this?
-
It's Official: These Are *the* It-Girl Uggs of Winter 2025Selena Gomez just solidified it.
-
I'm a Shopping Editor—These Are the Cool Shoes I Care About From theReplica Store Black Friday SaleTake up to 60% off 2025 shoe trends inside.

