Why is shopping for jeans so hard? I mean seriously, I'm a shopping editor and I still end up tearing my hair out when trying to decipher the minuscule differences between straight, slim and regular-fit jeans. But as always, seems to be the case with these things, you spend months hunting down the perfect pair then three come along at once.
I haven't ordered much over the last six months, however, on a whim, I decided to order a few straight-leg styles from ASOS, hoping that out of three pairs at least one would turn out to be a winner. One was from Topshop, one from a brand called Reclaimed Vintage and one from Other Stories, and you know what? They're all fab. I have a dilemma on my hands—which one do I choose? From Topshop's longline high-waisters to Other Stories' classic appeal, scroll down to see the styles and read my verdict. The jury is out.
Other Stories
Style Notes: I've heard lots of good things about Other Stories' denim, however, for some reason I've never taken the plunge and bought a pair myself. This Keeper Cropped leg pair really is a classic straight-leg style, with its slim leg and waist-hugging fit. I opted for my usual size W28 and they are true to size, but the denim fabric is quite rigid, so take note if you prefer a stretchier fit. They also come with a multi-button fastening, which is a nice touch, and an oh-so-subtle distressed finish, ideal if you want to embrace that true '90s throwback feel.
SHOP THE STYLE
Topshop
Style Notes: I have to say I am a real Topshop denim devotee, and some of my favourite pairs have come from the store. I didn't think I would love this pair, which comes with a longer leg length, however, thrown together with the super high waist, it offers unexpected leg-lengthening benefits. That being said, it probably isn't so good for petite individuals. I'm just over 5'7" and they were a good length for me. They are probably the most distressed out of the three, but it still feels like a suitably classic blue. This is a great pair for those who want a more dramatic silhouette and some serious waist-cinching appeal.
SHOP THE STYLE
ASOS: Reclaimed Vintage
Style Notes: The Reclaimed Vintage pair come in a more uniform true blue with a subtly distressed edging on the pocket. It's worth noting that I went one size up, following the advice from reviews, and they were a perfect fit (I would usually get a W28, but bought a W30). They were also snug on the bum, so possibly less good for those with a curvier silhouette. They were just the right amount of high-waisted and had a nice trouser leg width which will pair well with both sandals and boots. A solid 9/10 from me.
SHOP THE STYLE
Plus, shop my sandals:
Up Next: The 9 New-In Pieces I'm Loving This Week
-
I Know Good Jeans—Here Are 5 Pairs for Fall, Plus the Perfect Sweaters to Wear With ThemThe perfect duo.
-
I'm a Senior Shopping Editor—These 25 Elevated and Rich-LookingReplica Store Fall Sale Picks Have My AttentionChic and affordable? Yes, please.
-
The New Rules of Fall Denim: No Awkward Crops, No Basic Blues, No Barrel JeansElevate your denim collection inside.
-
Fashion People Just Gave Me 15 Fresh Ways to Wear Jeans Next MonthSave and style on repeat this fall.
-
The Denim Trends Celebrities Are Ditching, and What They're Wearing Instead for 2025Talk about a glow-up!
-
Forget Flats—Everyone With Good Taste Is Wearing These Boots With Jeans and a JacketPut these on your shopping list.
-
My Mom Is in Her 50s and Asked Me for Fashion Advice—8 ChicReplica Store Outfits I Put Together for Her Under $425Outdated prints and "ugly" shoes included.
-
No, Really—This Denim Color Is Easier to Style Than Blue *and* Black JeansAnd everyone with taste is wearing it with loafers for fall.
