I Asked Fashion Editors About Their Favorite Fall J.Crew Items—They're These 14

We, the fashion editors atBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing , simply can't get enough of J.Crew right now. The collections have been top-notch with Olympia Gayot at the helm of womenswear. Given the adoration of the brand in general, I thought I'd ask my fellow fashion editors about the specific new fall J.Crew items they love the most.
Below, you'll uncover the editor-approved fall items in question. As a preview, you'll notice everything from gorgeous knitwear to beautiful jackets that have the power to become new wardrobe staples. Oh, there's also a curation of standout shoes and accessories.
Keep scrolling to check out the best fall items from J.Crew.
"The thing that I'm most excited to wear this fall is sweater sets. I love layering up, and I know for a fact that I'll be cozy in this set. You can't go wrong with cashmere, and I could wear the vest in September and add the cardigan on top in October." — Mayhew
"Here's your sign not to overlook J.Crew Collection items. They're often a touch more forward, and this beautiful skirt is a perfect example. It's the kind of piece that feels very 'fashion person' while still being wearable." — LaPlaca
"Good ankle boots are a must-buy for fall, and these ones are exactly the kind I was looking for. I love that these have just the smallest heels, making them easy to wear on a busy day without hurting my feet. These also look like they pair perfectly with straight-leg jeans." — Grace O'Connell-Joshua, assistant shopping editor
Now, shop more amazing J.Crew items:
This post was published at an earlier date and has since been updated.

Bobby Schuessler is a fashion editor with over a decade of editorial experience covering shopping, style, and beauty. He's spent 10 years atBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing , currently leading the market team to deliver highly covetable and convertible content. He creates data-driven shopping guides featuring top retailers likeReplica Store, Shopbop, and Net-a-Porter and is at the forefront ofBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing 's shopping tentpole strategies, including Amazon Prime Day. He also works on branded content initiatives and appears on camera in video and shopping livestream franchises.
-
I Got Stares and Compliments at a Boston Coffee Shop While Wearing This J.Crew Approved Fall Outfit
Shop the effortless three-piece look.
-
Wait, Everything Is on Sale at J.Crew—These 29 Elegant Fall Finds Are the Standouts
Get 40% off full-priced items.
-
J.Crew Just Partnered With the Luxury Afrofuturist Jewelry Brand You Should Know About—6 Gorgeous Pieces From the Capsule Collection
An elegant collaboration with Khiry's Jameel Mohammed.
-
Cool-Girl Fall Era Loading—31 Picks From Zara, J.Crew, and Gap That Fit the Bill
I'm a senior shopping editor and these have my stamp of approval.
-
I'm the Creative Director at J.Crew—These Are the New Fall Items I Tell Everyone to Buy
Olympia Gayot's favorites.
-
J.Crew Just Released a New Generation of Its Iconic Rollneck Sweaters
The chicest fall sweater.
-
Dresses Aren't Only for Summer—These 35 J.Crew, Reformation, and Anthro Fall Styles Prove Just That
The best fall dress arrivals.
-
Wait, J.Crew Is 30% Off Sitewide Right Now—These Are the Chic Fall Pieces in My Cart
The fall 2025 collection is so good.