I've Been a Stylist for 14 Years—These 5 Winter Staples Have Never Once Failed Me

It’s funny how some years, it feels almost impossible to shop for the go-to fashion items you love to wear on repeat—for example, if you aren’t a fan of red, I can only imagine the fun you had in 2023 trying to buy a cute sweater in literally any other color. And if you aren’t particularly into barrel-leg jeans, I’m so sorry for the journey you've been on lately.
The good news is, it's the winter of 2024 (very soon to be 2025), and if you’re a fellow lover of elevated basics, this is a great time to be alive and have internet access. There’s really such a lot on offer this season when it comes to shopping for pieces that are chic and effortless, including the handful of winter wardrobe staples I’ve relied on as a stylist. From reliable knits to outerwear to footwear, these are the items that have helped me make getting dressed easy for at least a decade. So whether you’re looking to treat yourself a little splurge (with zero regrets, given the cost per wear) or are sticking to more affordable buys, here are a bunch of ways to shop the six winter items that I never regret shopping.
A Covetable (and Roomy) Bag
Winter means hats, gloves, and scarves, and it specifically means taking them off just about every time you enter a shop or sit down at a cafe. Do yourself a favor, and carry a chic bag that actually has room to stash them.
Slightly Dramatic Coats
A long coat has the power to take even my laziest winter look and turn it into something. Whether your vibe is faux fur, an attached scarf, or just a super-elegant silhouette, a little bit of drama is an immediate outfit upgrade, and my personal shortcut to getting out the door without overthinking my outfit.
Mock-Croc Accessories
Fall and winter outfits sometimes demand mock croc accessories. It just makes sense, I don't make the rules, and I won't be taking any further questions at this time.
Neutral-ish Crewneck Knits
I can't get enough crewneck knits, from my ultra-soft cashmere to some under-$50 styles from Zara that somehow don't mind going in the washing machine non-stop all winter long. Wearing as a sweater if just the beginning—if 2024 has taught us anything, it's that we should also be styling our sweaters as a scarf, and tied under our chins when we're in need of a make-shift hood.
Not-Quite-Flat Boots
There's maybe no greater achievement than finding a great black ankle boot with a heel so tiny it wears like a flat. I find having just that little bit of lift makes such a difference when you need an outfit to work from running around all day to dinner at night—plus a few extra mils can be the difference between jeans that soak up rain off the street, and jeans that don't.
Natalie Cantell is an NYC-based style director, creative consultant, and fashion editor, who regularly contributes from Paris. She was the executive director of Who What Wear and Marie Claire’s brand studio until 2023, and now freelances globally on shoots, stories, and special projects.
-
The Chicest Fashion People I Know Love COS—Here's What's Worth Buying From Their Major Sitewide Sale
Take 25% off.
By Judith Jones
-
Did Meghan Markle Really Just Share a Link to Everything in Her Closet?
Well, at least her favorite pieces.
By Eliza Huber
-
Hold Up! 5Replica Store Staples That'll Definitely Elevate Your Spring Outfits
Spring shopping made easy.
By Chichi Offor
-
Fact: Stylish Women in Italy, France, and NY Will Ditch Everything to Wear This Elegant Dress All Summer
Manifesting warm weather right now.
By Lauren Adhav
-
I Found a Trove of Cool-Girl Basics From theReplica Store Sale—31 Chic Standouts
These have closet-staple status.
By Jennifer Camp Forbes
-
I'm a Shopping Editor—6 Spring Basics I'm Over and 6 I'm Going to Wear All the Time
Basics don't have to be boring.
By Audry Hiaoui
-
The Good Stuff, Basics and Shoes—30Replica Store Styles That Will Fit Into Any Fashion Person's Wardrobe
New closet staples.
By Bobby Schuessler
-
I'm a Parent Who's Always Searching for Cute Kids' Clothing and Toys—Yes to These Items
Standout selects.
By Bobby Schuessler