I'm Sure '90s It Girls Would Freak Out Over These 32 Fall J.Crew Finds

Long live maxi skirts and micro-shades—two staples of '90s style. Between Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy's New York street style and Miuccia Prada's pre-smartphone runways, the time period between 1990 and 1999 may be my favorite yet. Although I didn't exactly live through it as a Gen Z fashion editor, every scroll on Pinterest provides me more and more opportunities to channel my inner Kate Moss and Julia Roberts, two leading ladies of the decade.
Known for its preppy, sophisticated style, J.Crew is certainly serving up elevated basics and chic silhouettes that all the It girls of the time were wearing. Olympia Gayot's new era at J.Crew has ushered in stylish garments that rival minimalist cult designers, a major plus in my book as someone who's slowly building their forever closet.
While I've dipped my toe into Y2K butterfly tops and low-rise jeans, there's nothing quite as comfortable to me as neutral long-sleeve shirts, boxy menswear jackets, and oversize denim jeans. Add a tortoiseshell headband, some vampy Chanel nail polish à la CBK, and a sleek black purse, and you're practically a carbon copy of the coolest fashion people back in the day.
Below, you'll find all the J.Crew staples that work just as well today as they would have back then.
WHO: Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy
WHO: Julia Roberts
WHO: Iman
WHO: Gwyneth Paltrow
WHO: Halle Berry
WHO: Kate Moss
Shop more J.Crew finds:

Ana Escalante is an award-winning journalist and Gen Z editor known for her sharp takes on fashion and culture. She’s covered everything from Copenhagen Fashion Week to Roe v. Wade protests as the Editorial Assistant at Glamour after earning her journalism degree at the University of Florida in 2021. At Who What Wear, Ana mixes wit with unapologetic commentary in long-form fashion and beauty content, creating pieces that resonate with a digital-first generation. If it’s smart, snarky, and unexpected, chances are her name’s on it.
-
I've Been Wearing My J.Crew Rollneck Sweater Every Day—Here's What I'm Wearing With It to Look Chic in NYC
I already want another color.
-
Gwyneth Paltrow and Apple Martin Star in GapStudio's Fall Campaign—Shop Wholesale Replica Bag Collection
The mother and daughter model the new 38-piece capsule.
-
I Love the Sweaters at J.Crew, COS, and Zara RN—40 Worth Adding to Your Cart
These will elevate your fall outfits.
-
I Got Stares and Compliments at a Boston Coffee Shop While Wearing This J.Crew Approved Fall Outfit
Shop the effortless three-piece look.
-
Wait, Everything Is on Sale at J.Crew—These 29 Elegant Fall Finds Are the Standouts
Get 40% off full-priced items.
-
J.Crew Just Partnered With the Luxury Afrofuturist Jewelry Brand You Should Know About—6 Gorgeous Pieces From the Capsule Collection
An elegant collaboration with Khiry's Jameel Mohammed.
-
FYI: If You Wear This Dated Sneaker Trend in Fall 2025, Make Sure It's With Baggy Jeans
Because Gwyneth Paltrow says so.
-
Cool-Girl Fall Era Loading—31 Picks From Zara, J.Crew, and Gap That Fit the Bill
I'm a senior shopping editor, and these have my stamp of approval.