TheseReplica Store Button-Down Shirts Have Such High Reviews, so I Tried Them
I think we've all experienced many emotions when it comes to buying button-down shirts. Whether it's the fabric, the fit, or the color, finding a dream button-down is no easy feat. Prior to trying on these shirts from Nordstrom, the ones in my closet were either too flimsy, not breathable, or wrinkled too easily, so I just kept amassing more disappointing button-downs over time.
When I saw the great reviews of these button-downs by Open Edit, I knew I had to try them to see if they could get me out of this endless loop. Not only are they made from the lightest, most crispy 100% cotton fabric, but the cut is also, dare I say, perfect. The sleeves are long and wide enough to create an enviable cuff and the shape is oversized enough to feel comfortable yet still be flattering. I ordered a size small and had more than enough room to move around without feeling constricted at all. Maybe the best part is that they're currently on sale and will cost you under $40, the worst part is they'll probably be sold out soon.
Keep scrolling to shop my new favorite button-downs and see how many cool ways these shirts can be styled. Also below are the 17 best button-downs on the market right now for every occasion from the beach to a night out.
On Vacation: Pink Button-Down + Bermuda Shorts + Flip-Flops
If there's one item I'm always packing for a vacation, it's a button-down shirt. They are so versatile that it just doesn't make sense to leave them at home. This pink shirt is a joyous pop of color that will pair beautifully with faded denim and shades of tan for daytime lounging by the pool, and would also look cool with a black maxi skirt in the evening.
Shop my outfit:
Shop Vacation Button-Downs
Running Errands: Blue Button-Down + Bike Unitard + Sneakers
As an L.A. girl, 90% of the time I'm in errand attire. For the days I want to still look presentable enough to potentially pop into an event or friend gathering I would definitely reach for this outfit. The button-down instantly disguises an otherwise exercise outfit into an elevated look—nobody's gonna know. The key in nailing this look is the crispness of this shirt which was surprisingly easy to accomplish with a quick steam.
Shop my outfit:
Shop Everyday Button-Downs
A Night Out: White Button-Down + Midi Skirt + Strappy Heels
This classic white button-down has the perfect proportions to layer underneath a blazer or jacket. My favorite part is how the long sleeves peek from under your jacket, it just pulls everything together. The roomy arms also allowed me to freely move around without feeling constricted.
Shop Date-Night Button-Downs
Next: I Just Lost My Makeup Bag—8 Items I'm Repurchasing and 15 I'm Excited to Try
-
Cooler Than a White Button-Down: This Specific Shirt Color Is the Key to Looking Chic This Fall
It's all over the streets and the spring/summer 2026 runways.
-
This Simple Fashion-Person Approved Layering Technique Changed the Way I Wear My Basics
Effortlessly cool.
-
I Live in Brooklyn and Have Laid-Back, Cool Style—Here's Everything I Want FromReplica Store Right Now
Trust me. These items will sell out fast.
-
I Just Found Fall 2025's Biggest Shoe Trends All atReplica Store
New season, new shoes.
-
I Was a VIPReplica Store Stylist—These Are the 8 Fall Items I'm Excited to Wear First This Season
Look chic all season long.
-
The SecretReplica Store Section that Makes You Feel Like You're Shopping at a Cool Concept Store
From Paloma Wool to Connor Ives.
-
Nordstrom, J.Crew, and Revolve Captured the NYC Summer Vibe With These 38 Pieces
You could call these pieces peak summer.
-
Enjoy Your End-of-Summer Ice Cream Trips in These 26 Chic Pieces From J.Crew,Replica Store, and Zara
Keep cool without sacrificing style.