I Aggressively Decluttered My Footwear Last Year—the 5 Styles I Added Are All I Wear

The zen that followed my 2023 shoe culling was so noteworthy I actually wrote a story about it. It was a year ago that I created my little footwear capsule of just a handful of pairs, and they did a fantastic job of getting me through fall and winter. I was still on the hunt for chic flats when the story went live, bringing the total to six pairs—but otherwise, my hit list included classic Sambas, some everyday black ankle boots, riding boots, kitten-heeled boots, and low slingbacks.
All of these proved to be excellent investments, and most are still in rotation for this season. We have had a couple of retirements: Those OG Sambas are so thrashed they’ve been relegated to rainy-day status, and my light-brown slingbacks have migrated into my spring/summer wardrobe. There are already a couple of fresh additions to the mix. Plus, I have my eye on a couple of new pairs of heels as well—but not because the shopping dams have completely burst! I’m just strategically expanding outside of phase one of the footwear capsule (investment neutrals) and getting a little more fun. Here’s what’s made the cut.
New Everyday Black Boots
Last year, I went without a low-heeled pair of black boots as a result of my culling, so it was the first thing on my list this season. There are loads of great options around, but these Massimo Dutti boots are the exact style I shopped—the round toe felt fresh, and the kitten heel is just right.
T-Bar Styles
If you love a Mary Jane but can't quite justify another pair, trending T-straps are the perfect way to mix it up. The low-heeled styles are my personal favorites, with bonus points for a slingback—mine are from Dolce Vita and are *so comfortable* I've been wearing them nonstop with sheer socks this week in Paris.
Loafer Boots
Honestly, no one is more surprised than I am that loafer boots are on this list. But when I bought the above pair of Massimo Dutti black ankle boots, I impulse-added a similar suede pair to my cart, and they're so comfortable I've been wearing them nonstop ever since.
Colorful Sneakers
After thrashing the classic OG Sambas in my footwear capsule last year, I've been ready to inject a little more personality south of my ankles. The thing about colorful sneakers is that you wear them just like a neutral with absolutely no regard as to whether they "go" with what you're wearing. It works, I promise.
Loafers
As great as those loafer boots are, sometimes you just want to have a little sock moment. I recently rediscovered a pair of Gucci Horsebit brown velvet loafers that were hiding at the top of my closet, and they're as good as ever—which is exactly what I told myself when I was justifying the purchase, so I love that for me.

Natalie Cantell is an NYC-based style director, creative consultant, and fashion editor, who regularly contributes from Paris. She was the executive director of Who What Wear and Marie Claire’s brand studio until 2023, and now freelances globally on shoots, stories, and special projects.
-
Striped Shirts Are Always In, But Not *This* In—These 28 Will Make Every Outfit Cool
Fact.
-
Not All Designer Pieces Achieve It Status, But These 14 Luxury Finds Are Set to by Fall
Smart, long-term purchases.
-
If You Care About What Fall Sweater Trend It Girls Are Already Wearing, It's This '90s One
Spotted on Olivia Rodrigo in London.
-
Katie Holmes's Tip for Looking Rich? Lose the Flip-Flops and Wear These Classic Flats (in *This* Color) Instead
A shoe trend to take from summer to fall.
-
Bring On the Transitional Weather—29 Perfectly Chic Pieces FromReplica Store to Wear Straight Through Fall
Effortless dressing right this way.
-
This Unexpected Shoe Color Made All the Difference in Pamela Anderson's Elegant Outfit
Shop the fun trend.
-
Prepare to See Rickea Jackson at a Lot More Than Just WNBA Games
Fashion girl loading.
-
This Shoe Color Trend Is Chicer Than Black, Burgundy, and Brown
Kaia Gerber agrees.