A few seasons ago, Saint Laurent took coats to a whole new length, and fashion people are still talking about it. While most of us had been wearing wool coats that grazed our calves for decades, Saint Laurent suggested floor-sweeping coats in all shapes and sizes. Suddenly, everyone’s eyes were on wool coats, whether they were trenches or in a bold shade of berry. While I love a floor sweeper, practicality is key, and a New York City winter is no friend to long hemlines. To avoid dragging every drop of snow and dirt on the streets, the NYC fashion crowd has settled on owning a broad range of wool coats in many lengths, but after many failed online orders, I decided to put the best options in this coat trend to the test.
Are wool coats absolutely in? Yes. Are they warm enough for a New York City winter? Now, that’s highly debatable. Regardless of warmth, I still spent a week in them and was surprised at not only how warm they were but also how stylish they looked among my wardrobe. Below, find my reviews and thoughts on the coats of the season.
Shop the coat:
COS is one of those brands that every fashion person just so happens to have in their closet. I remember one day bopping into theBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing office and asking everyone where they got their coats. Most of them answered with COS. The brand's coats sell out fast, so if you're interested in one, don't hesitate. Plus, if you're looking to wear multiple layers, this one is perfectly oversize.
While this coat was amazing for layering, I gave it a 3/5 in the warmth category because it doesn't have any sort of lining. It's perfect for less frigid days or when worn with lots of layers.
Shop more COS coats:
Shop the coat:
This was the most complimented coat that I wore. I had multiple people ask me where I got it from. Reformation is another brand that I go to for elevated staples, and yes, that of course includes wool coats.
Most of my coats go to my calves and beyond, but having a cropped option in my closet is perfect for a night out. I must warn you, though, this also means there's less warmth.
Shop more Reformation coats:
Shop the coat:
I first saw this wool coat during a fashion week preview, and I fell in love immediately. While looking for a designer coat that actually matches the hefty price tag, I discovered this one, and I’ve been wearing it to almost every occasion ever since. The navy color looks cooler than ever when styled with black, and every detail on this coat screams luxury: exquisite buttons, striped lining, and hella warmth.
This coat is perfection, but I must note that it is pretty fitted, which doesn't leave much room for layering.
Shop more Dorothee Schumacher coats:
Shop the coat:
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, you’ll want to get lost in the shelves at Abercrombie. It quite literally has it all, and a wool coat for $200 is an amazing deal. This ended up being one of the warmest brands that I tried, and I’m telling all of my friends to shop here instead of wherever they were shopping before.
This is the perfect everyday coat and got one of the highest ratings, so I have nothing bad to say about it.
Shop more Abercrombie Fitch coats:
Shop the coat:
The voluminous belted wool coat from Other Stories caught my eye immediately, and it’s the coat that I wish I could buy in multiple colors. It’s quite roomy, leaving lots of space for layering up. This coat has quickly become my daily go-to.
Another coat that I absolutely adore. No notes here.
Shop more Other Stories coats:
-
I Just Found the Chicest Sweaters, Coats, and Boots FromReplica Store's Black Friday Sale—EnjoyThese finds will sell out by December 1.
-
I'm a Mom With 2 Young Kids—These 31 EasyReplica Store Black Friday Sale Picks Make Me Feel StylishThese are guaranteed to sell out.
-
Wait, Gap's Pre Black Friday Sale Is So Good—25 Elevated Winter Basics That Have My AttentionChic and affordable? Done and done.
-
31 Maxi Coats From Shopbop, COS, and Mango That Have My Undivided AttentionFloor-sweeping styles only.
-
Sorry to My Black Coats, But Chic Women in NYC Convinced Me to Prioritize This Color InsteadFrom Gisele to Katie.
-
The Only 6 Winter Coat Trends Celebrities Seem to Care About -
I Want a Rich-Looking Wardrobe—33 Perfect Picks FromReplica Store's (Early) Black Friday SaleGet a head start with these chic gems.
-
I'm Manifesting Chic Winter Outfits—30 Affordable and Stylish Walmart Finds That Fit the BillCheap *and* cheerful.
