Well, there you have it. The two-day extravaganza that was this year’s amped-up Amazon Prime Day has finally come to an end. From beauty must-haves to fashion finds and everything in between, you guys shopped a lot, and we have the receipts to prove it. Well, not literally, it’s more like the receipts you hear referenced in memes.
What we actually have is the data on what our readers bought in bulk, and today I’m here to spill. So what were the best-selling (and predominately extremely affordable) items our readers snagged by the dozen or, in some cases, by the hundreds? From eyeliner to earrings to underwear, just keep scrolling to see all the Amazon items and, of course, shop them in case any happen to catch your eye this time around.
Beauty
Stila
Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
This top seller is known for giving you the perfect wing that lasts all day, even in the face of humidity.
Bliss
That's Incredi-Peel Glycolic Resurfacing Pads
Have a spa-quality facial in the comfort of your home with these glycolic acid exfoliating pads.
Bioderma
Sensibio H2O Micellar Water
The best French pharmacy makeup remover can be at your door in the click of a button.
R+Co
Badlands Dry Shampoo Paste
Intrigued by the idea of a dry shampoo paste? Same.
LilyAna Naturals
Retinol Cream Moisturizer
This affordable retinol cream has over 5000 reviews and four and a half stars.
Crest
3D White Professional Effects Whitestrips
Next time you're reading in bed, why not get some teeth whitening in?
Dr. Brenner
Vitamin C Serum
Vitamin C is Wholesale Replica Bag
beauty ingredient on my radar.
Bloom
Rejuvenating Eye Cream and Potion
Potion? I like the sound of that.
InstaNatural
Hyaluronic Acid Serum
Hydrate your skin without breaking the bank.
Mario Badescu
Drying Lotion
According to its description, this drying lotion "helps target pesky pimples while you sleep."
Olaplex
No.4 Bond Maintenance Shampoo
Our readers with color-treated hair can't get enough of this shampoo.
Revlon
One-Step Hair Dryer
Volumizer Hot Air Brush
Save time and bathroom space with this two-in-one hair dryer and brush.
HotLife
LED Lighted Makeup Mirror
I think I actually need this for myself.
Clothing
J.Crew
Mercantile Short Sleeve V-Neck T-Shirt
You can never have enough white tees.
Levi's
Mid Rise Classic Skinny Jeans
Levi's will never fail you.
Calvin Klein
Invisibles No Panty Line Thong 3 Pack
Editor-approved.
Baleaf
High Waist Workout Yoga Running Compression Shorts
Since starting as an intern back in 2013, Nicole Akhtarzad Eshaghpour has held several roles here atBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing
, and she is currently Editor-at-Large. Upon joining, she was a senior about to graduate from business school at USC. Fast-forward to 2025, and she's moved to NYC from her hometown of Beverly Hills and spends her workdays a little differently from when she was just starting out. Currently, she focuses on a weekly mélange of shopping content and her Trust Me—Buy This newsletter. As far as her personal style goes, she's largely drawn to neutral, classic pieces but will always make an exception for something colorful or bejeweled as long as it's deemed worthy enough. After all, the only thing she loves more than a party is dressing up for one. On her downtime, she can usually be found at home eating something delicious and trying to force her husband to watch Summer House.