It was once far too easy to spot a non-designer item in a sea of designer ones, but these days, designers have gotten quite good at whipping up pieces that would leave even the most advanced luxury experts stumped. Under-$150 tops, shoes, and dresses can appear just as pricey as over-$1000 ones, if not more, making it significantly easier to build a wardrobe of both designer and non-designer items that blend seamlessly together.
As a fashion editor who wants to look expensive but can't afford to buy only designer pieces, there's hardly anything that brings me more satisfaction than discovering these sartorial anomalies. Because of that, I decided to turn my obsession into work by going through all of my favorite retailers—from Nordstrom and Moda Operandi to H&M and J.Crew—and plucking out shockingly expensive-looking and actually expensive pieces that go together like two side-by-side pieces of a puzzle. A perfect fit.
Scroll down to shop the selection.
Turtleneck tops are a classic for good reason. They're eternally chic.
This colorway just dropped, and damn, I'm in love.
This dress is giving chic Laura Harrier vibes.
Tortoiseshell sunglasses can sometimes feel even more elegant than black ones.
This brand's website is basically a treasure trove for gorgeous ready-to-wear.
If it's off the shoulder and slightly drapey, I want it. You can hold me to that.
The darker wash makes this long denim skirt look very luxe.
If I didn't know better, I'd think this belt cost more than $300.
Easy and elegant.
This braided Anthro tote will bring forth all the compliments. Trust me—I've read the TikTok comments.
For all of your Hamptons and Nantucket weekend trips this summer.
I can't get enough of big '80s-era earrings.
This color is rich with a capital R.
Liberowe's coats, dresses, and tops are genuine pieces of art.
A maxi skirt to wear forever.
Kiss the ring.
If a white vest is good enough for Sofia Richie to wear it to her wedding, it's good enough for you—end of story.
I just tried these on at theReplica Store Anniversary Sale preview, and I was extremely impressed.
This is one of Katie Holmes's new favorite bags.
In love.
Color me impressed.
Comes in black and white.
Far too classic to pass up.
The two-tone colorway allows for all kinds of jewelry options.
I've Slacked my entire team about this stunning Abercrombie dress.
A literal dream.
A pretty pick for fall.
The retro energy is high.
A crisp, white, button-down shirt is elite—period.
I'm acting fast to get a pair of my own.
This material feels like literal butter.
The shape of these trousers makes them look so pricey.
This top is perfect for showing off a great pair of earrings.
If you don't already own these, now's your chance.
I'm sick over this dress. For real, someone call a doctor.
Dare to wear this all-lace maxi. You won't regret it.
Simply perfect.
Just easy.
I tried on so many pieces at Madewell last week, and these white trousers were my favorite.
The shape of this bag is gorgeous, but it's the color that really won me over.
It's a need, not a want.
Classic old money shoes that'll never go out of style.
This post was published at an earlier date and has since been updated.
-
My Fashion Friends Put These 30 Exceptionally Good Pieces On My Radar This MonthGood luck picking just one favorite.
-
6 Fashion Editors, 36 Summer Buys—Inside Our Summer 2025 Mood BoardsEverything inspiring our wardrobes this season.
-
Bring On the Transitional Weather—29 Perfectly Chic Pieces FromReplica Store to Wear Straight Through FallEffortless dressing right this way.
-
The Dresses From Mango Are Undeniably Top-Tier—These 25 Impressive Styles Are Guaranteed to Turn HeadsThere's nothing like a great dress.
-
I'm Not Over Summer, But I'm Ready for Fall—33 Transitional Pieces on My Wish ListSuede skirts, leather sneakers, and so much more.
-
If Younger Me Knew You Can Shop the Chicest Mall Brands Online, She'd Be Impressed—30 Standouts From Gap, J.Crew, and Banana RepublicEffortless and affordable? Yes, please.
-
What You Should and Should Not Wear to Every Major Sporting EventFrom a Liberty game to the French Open.
-
Fall Is Already on My Mind—I'm Prepping My Wardrobe With These 31 ElevatedReplica Store FindsEach piece is chic and on sale.
