Recently, something dawned on me as I was online shopping: Gap, J.Crew, and Banana Republic feel like the trifecta for best cold-weather basics right now. Between the three, I've come across some of the strongest of the season.
At Gap, I know I can rely on them for wardrobe staples I'll wear over and over—making the cost per wear an obvious benefit. I tend to gravitate towards pieces that aren't branded, so I like that many of its designs are understated and nondescript.
For J.Crew, I always head straight for The Cashmere Shop—its devoted section for all things cashmere. Aside from that, my most-worn sweater currently is the new rollneck, and I can confirm at least four other editors on our team own it too (and there are probably more).
Banana Republic, on the other hand, is the retailer I stumbled into—literally—this year. On my first day at the office, I wasn't sure what to wear (that's when I realized much of my wardrobe during the spring was quite sheer). I happened to walk past one of its stores, wandered in, and left with the chicest black, knee-length boatneck dress. I've been a fan ever since.
If you're a minimalist looking to stay warm as the weather gets colder, I've rounded up what's currently in my cart from each brand.
Gap
Gap
Cashsoft Stretch Turtleneck Sweater
I recommend looking through Gap's entire Cashsoft line.
How do I live in New York and not own a scarf? It's alarming.
Gap
Cashsoft Drawcord Hood
I'd like to get this hood for the depths of winter.
Gap
100% Cotton Oversized Sweater
This 100% Cotton Oversized Sweater keeps selling out in every color.
Gap
Cashsoft Crop Cardigan
A cute cherry-red cardigan.
Gap
Cashsoft Oversized V-Neck Sweater
Gap
Cashsoft Crewneck Sweater
Mixing black with navy has been trending.
Gap
Vintagesoft Zip Hoodie
It's always nice to have a go-to zip-up hoodie to throw on under wool coats.
Gap
Recycled Lightweight Oversized Quilted Liner Jacket
Speaking of wool coats, I saw fashion people layer them with lightweight quilted liner jackets to make them warmer.
Gap
Low Rise '90s Loose Jeans
Loose jeans to wear over thermals.
J.Crew
j.crew
2025 Rollneck Sweater
My most-worn sweater right now. It's so comfortable.
j.crew
Cashmere Classic-Fit Crewneck Sweater
A classic cashmere crewneck.
j.crew
Relaxed Crewneck Pullover
This heavier-weight relaxed pullover.
j.crew
Carolyn Turtleneck Sweater in Merino Wool
I want this merino wool turtleneck that costs less than $60.
j.crew
2025 Brushed Cashmere Rollneck Sweater
Wait, I had no idea there was a cashmere version of the J.Crew roll-neck I've been wearing on repeat.
j.crew
Cashmere-Wool Blend Poncho
I know I would wear this all the time.
j.crew
Brushed Cashmere Rugby Sweater
j.crew
Cashmere High V-Neck Sweater
I like the high neckline on this one.
jcrew
Cashmere Boatneck Sweater
Somewhere between a scarf and a wrap.
j.crew
Cashmere Tech-Touch Gloves
j.crew
Leather Tech-Touch Gloves
Banana Republic
Banana Republic
Cotton V-Neck Sweater
This viral sweater has been on my wish list.
Banana Republic
Lightweight Cashmere V-Neck Sweater
The lighter-weight cashmere version.
Banana Republic
Luxe Wool-Blend Turtleneck T-Shirt
Banana Republic
Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater
Banana Republic
Lightweight Cashmere Crew-Neck Sweater
You can't go wrong with this.
Banana Republic
Luxe Wool-Blend Crew-Neck T-Shirt
Banana Republic
Relaxed Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater
Love this in the color Port Wine.
Banana Republic
Brushed Alpaca-Wool Blend Scarf
Banana Republic
The Perfect Balaclava by Hat Attack
Another color-weather accessory.
Banana Republic
Italian Leather Cashmere-Lined Gloves
Cashmere-lined gloves feel like such a luxury.