On the heels of my story about my mom's affinity for affordable purchases, I set out to send her rich-looking picks that I recently came across when doing research for an upcoming fall shopping story. Two retailers stood out in particular in this endeavor: Nordstrom and Old Navy. Both offer a wide variety of budget-friendly finds that lend a boost of rich vibes to any closet. There's truly nothing like a cheap score that would have any fashionable person doing a double take.
Ahead, I rounded up 22 affordable yet chic finds for fall 2025 from Nordstrom and Old Navy. All but three pieces are under $100. Think elevated sweaters, cool jeans, suede gems, pretty dresses, plus many more closet staples that you'll wear this season and beyond. Here's to frugal shopping without sacrificing style.
Shop theReplica Store Picks
This cashmere sweater comes in so many chic colors.
Brown suede jackets are having a moment.
The Row bags comes to mind.
Hello, perfect '90s-inspired Levi's jeans.
Scarf sweaters are super chic.
Nothing like a sleek little black dress.
Ruched loafers are a personal favorite.
Tell me this sweater doesn't look expensive.
Perfect for jumping on the suede bag trend.
Dark-wash jeans make any outfit look richer.
Another stellar sweater with a built-in scarf.
Shop the Old Navy Picks
The brown version of this barn jacket already sold out.
These might be my favorite cuffed jeans out there.
Boatneck tops are a true classic.
This burgundy lace-trim dress is great alone or layered.
Endless styling possibilities.
This satin skirt is an instant closet staple.
A neutral sweater to wear with everything.
A simple yet chic dress for an upcoming fall wedding outfit.
More cool dark-wash jeans.
Now, a suede button-down worth considering.
Corduroy pants are a hit with fashion people.
-
I'm a Shopping Director and I Already Saved $341 From theReplica Store Black Friday Sale—These Are the Best ItemsUp to 60% off coveted items!
-
If You’re Closet Needs an Update, Bring It to Life With These New Items From H&M, Old Navy, MangoYou're due for a winter wardrobe refresh.
-
I'm a Shopping Expert, and This Is the One Item I'm Buying First FromReplica Store's Early Black Friday SaleIt makes for a great holiday gift, too.
-
This Denim Wash Will Have You Looking Like a Fashion Person This WinterThese jeans make any outfit look more expensive.
-
My Mom Is 56, and I'm 22—29 Chic Zara Finds We're Loving RNSee the rich-looking pieces inside.
-
I Just Created 8 Spectacular Fall Outfits FromReplica Store for Under $500Major inspo ahead.
-
No Need to Wait Until Black Friday for All the Good Deals—These Under $100 Sale Finds are atReplica Store Right NowUp to 60% off.
-
My Friends and I Love Old Navy—16 Early Black Friday Deals I Immediately Sent to the Group ChatGet 50% off chic winter essentials.
