Hailey Bieber and J.Lo Swear By This One £19 Lip Liner That Can't Stay in Stock

Earlier this year, when Hailey Bieber exclusively toldBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing UK all about her signature lip combo, I peeped the lip liner she was using. If you've seen any of Bieber's videos, you may have noticed that she's often using a specific lip liner. It comes in a wooden pencil and is now instantly recognisable to beady-eyed makeup lovers. The one in question? Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil.
@whowhatwear.uk Thanks to @Hailey Bieber, we now know how to create the most delicious summer lip combo 🍓 #haileybieber #haileybiebermakeup #rhodeskin @rhode skin #strawberrygirl
♬ original sound -Best Knockoff Luxury Clothing
Sharing how she creates her neutral lip look above, Bieber says, "I start off with a liner that I really love... I love doing just a nude liner to kind of contour and enhance the lips." Meanwhile, she lines her lips with a Make Up For Ever lip pencil. She has previously shared that she loves to use the pencil in the shade Anywhere Caffeine, which looks very similar to the one used in this video, if not the very shade.
We've even spotted Jennifer Lopez using the exact same lip pencil in a recent Instagram video, showing how she creates her red lipstick look. "I always start with a neutral pencil," she says as she lines her lips with the lip liner, explaining that she prefers to use a neutral colour rather than a red pencil, even when wearing a red lipstick on top. "It makes the lips look fuller and plumper," she says.
Of course, when a product comes with this level of celebrity endorsement, it doesn't stay in stock for long—the Anywhere Caffeine shade is completely sold out everywhere. However, if you shop around you can find a few shades of Artist Color Pencil still in stock. If you've fallen for Bieber and J.Lo's exact shade, we've helped you out by whittling down some great dupes, most of which are also considerably cheaper than Make Up For Ever's £19 liner. Scroll on and thank us later.
Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil in Anywhere Caffeine
Shop More Make Up For Ever Lip Liners:
In-Stock Shades
Shop Make Up For Ever Anywhere Caffeine Lip Pencil Dupes:
TikTok says this one is another close match.
It's hard to tell which is which when you swatch this Charlotte Tilbury shade alongside Anywhere Caffeine.
Next Up: No Lie—I Tried Hailey Bieber's Blush Hack, and My Face Has Never Looked Better

Eleanor Vousden is the beauty editor for Who What Wear UK. She was previously deputy editor at Hairdressers Journal, health writer at Woman Home and junior beauty editor at Powder. She has also contributed to Wallpaper and Elle Collections.With a degree in fashion journalism from the London College of Fashion, she has 10 years of industry experience and has been highly commended at the BSME Talent Awards for her work on Powder and also contributed to the title winning Website of the Year at the PPA Awards.Eleanor’s journalistic focus is providing readers with honest and helpful beauty content. She has interviewed celebrity makeup artists, hairstylists and dermatologists throughout her career, as well as celebrities such as Hailey Bieber, Sarah Jessica Parker and Scarlett Johansson.
-
I Couldn't Help But Notice That L.A.'s Coolest Dressers Always Wear This Shoe Trend With Black Trousers
If you guessed ballet flats, you'd be wrong.
-
The Simple Styling Trick That Turns Pencil Skirts From Corporate to Chic in 5 Seconds or Less
It's completely free and ready to copy.
-
The Future Is Clear: This Pretty Dress Trend Will Dominate Lake Como, Capri, and Cannes Next Month
J.Lo is leading the movement.
-
Don't Buy New Jeans Without Reading My Review of J.Lo's New Favorite Pair
Here are my thoughts.
-
Now That Hailey Bieber Has Worn This Viral Miu Miu Item, It'll Be Sold Out in No Time
You'll see.
-
As Seen on Greenwich Street: A Surprisingly Chic Way to Wear Culottes (Yes, I Said Culottes) This Summer
I feel a trend catching on.
-
J.Lo! Hailey! Sienna! Sorry, Skinny Jeans, But Celebrities Are Keen to Thwart Your Return
No spandex, no problem.
-
Wait, Hailey and Kendall's Favorite Leggings Are on Sale RN? BRB
J.Lo is a fan too.