3 Designer Bags NYC Women Pay Superior Prices to Own

We consistently turn to NYC women for style inspiration. What can we say? This trendsetting set just gets it with their cool, effortless vibes. When we spot one of their noteworthy outfits, we essentially clock every outfit detail, but it's their accessories of choice—handbags, in particular—that really get us going. Sure, there's a smattering of bag silhouettes New Yorkers carry, but there are actually a few key styles this elite group seems to covet over others. In fact, many will apparently pay premium prices just to tote around said satchels around the city.
That's right, we caught up with Charles Gorra, CEO and founder of handbag resale brand Rebag (which has three stores in NYC), so he could fill us in on the handbags he sees New Yorkers shell out extra cash (even at the resale level) just to carry. There's one you could probably already guess as it's one of the most desirable bags of all time (ahem, the Hermès Birkin), but there are a few others that may surprise you.
Keep scrolling to uncover the exclusive handbags the women of New York City seem to crave. Plus, shop the picks, along with other must-have designer silhouettes.
"This is an It bag that Louis Vuitton can’t keep on the shelves—the demand is incredible, yet Louis Vuitton does not produce it in higher quantities. There are long waiting lists, and shoppers who are lucky enough to get their hands on one often take the opportunity to resell it on the secondary market for a premium. " — Charles Gorra
"The exclusivity surrounding this bag, and the difficulty in acquiring it, boost its resale value, placing the style well above its retail price. In fact, for each Birkin (and Kelly) handbag sold to Rebag in the month of August, Rebag is giving the seller an additional $500 credit on top of their quote." — Charles Gorra
"Similar to the Birkin, the Kelly is not only incredibly classic and versatile, but it's also often seen on the arm of the most fashionable celebrities, constantly putting it in the spotlight and making in an unfailing classic for the last several decades." — Charles Gorra
Shop more coveted designer bags:
Next, check out the fall handbag trends invading NYC.
Opening Image: Getty Images

Bobby Schuessler is a fashion editor with over a decade of editorial experience covering shopping, style, and beauty. He's spent 10 years atBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing , currently leading the market team to deliver highly covetable and convertible content. He creates data-driven shopping guides featuring top retailers likeReplica Store, Shopbop, and Net-a-Porter and is at the forefront ofBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing 's shopping tentpole strategies, including Amazon Prime Day. He also works on branded content initiatives and appears on camera in video and shopping livestream franchises.
-
Fashionphile's Done the Research: These Are the It Bags of 2025
The 2025 Resale Report is here.
-
Not Ready to Let Go of Sardine Summer? This Chic Bag Launch Will Help You Carry the Vibes Straight Through Fall
The first drop sold out, so these won't be around for long.
-
28 Accessories That'll Make Every Fall Outfit Look Elegant
These are the add-ons you need.
-
We Love You, Chocolate Brown, But This Is the Rich Bag Color Trend It Girls Are Wearing Now
Spotted on Ayo and Kendall at the Chanel show.
-
I’m a Senior Shopping Editor—Here’s Everything I Highly Recommend Buying From the Mango Sale
Get 30% off just about everything
-
I Want to Be Old Money, But I Work 9 to 5—These 23 Workbags Make Me Feel Rich
Carry everything in style.
-
Thanks to It Girls With Good Taste, This Anti-Trend Bag Style Is What Everyone Wants RN
Hailey Bieber just proved it again.
-
I'm a Stylist—These Are the Only Bags You Need for a Foolproof Capsule Collection
From Balenciaga to Phoebe Philo.