Fact vs Fiction: What's Accurate in The Assassination of Gianni Versace

Last night, one of the season's most highly anticipated new shows finally debuted. The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story's first episode was an intriguing opener that definitely made us excited for the season. In light of the debate over whether the show is an accurate portrayal or not, we decided to break down what was real and what was elaborated.
Fact: The murder scene in the show was mostly accurate. In 1997, Gianni Versace walked to the nearby News Café, where he purchased a magazine and coffee and returned to his home, where he was killed by Andrew Cunanan on his front steps.
Fiction: However, the real Antonio D’Amico disputes the scene where he is shown embracing Versace's dead body. “The picture of Ricky Martin holding the body in his arms is ridiculous,” D'Amico told The Guardian in July. “Maybe it’s the director’s poetic license, but that is not how I reacted...The house had stained glass windows so we couldn’t see what had happened from inside, so we had to open the gate. I saw Gianni lying on the steps, with blood around him. At that point, everything went dark. I was pulled away, I didn’t see any more."
Fact: The dead bird was also an accurate portrayal. During the murder, a dove was accidentally struck by a bullet fragment. Vulture tapped a reporter who covered the case at the time, who explained that the bird “sparked a panic that this was a Mafia from Sicily hit." As Slate explains, "The presence of a dead bird is a known mafia signature."
Fiction: According to the show, Cunanan had a conversation with Versace in San Francisco in 1990. However, it has never been definitively proven that Cunanan had prior contact with Versace before the murder.
Fact: Cunanan really did use his own name at a pawn shop. He pawned a gold coin only eight days before the shooting.

Erin got her start as aBest Knockoff Luxury Clothing intern in 2011—back when the site only published a single story per day. (We have since increased that number twentyfold.) She graduated magna cum laude from USC and lives in Los Angeles. In college, she also interned at Refinery29, where she was promoted to editorial assistant and then assistant editor. After nearly three years at R29, she came back to WWW in 2015, where she is now the Associate Director of Fashion News. From the Oscars to the Met Gala, she leads the site's entire red carpet coverage strategy. She specializes in celebrity and fashion news but also enjoys writing travel features and runway reports. She frequently contributes to WWW's social accounts and has a sizable following on her personal TikTok.
-
5 Street Style Trends from Milan Fashion Week That Will Be Everywhere This Fall
The go-to It items.
-
Giorgio Armani's 50th—and Final—Collection Paid Homage to the Late Designer's Legacy
Eighties supermodels, core house codes, and plenty of Armani gray were the capstone to a half-century of the iconic Italian house.
-
We Can't Stop Talking About Sydney Chandler, Sci-Fi's Newest Heroine
The star of the big, fun, and very scary Alien: Earth proves she's one to watch.
-
Rising Star Sophie Telegadis Wore The Vintage Dress of Her Dreams for Her Feature Film Debut
The emerging singer-songwriter and actress shares her exclusive TIFF photo diary.
-
The Conjuring: Last Rites Breakout Mia Tomlinson Is Scary Good
The star of this month's must-see horror film talks about her terrifying new role.
-
Viola Prettejohn Makes Stunning Venice Debut in Miu Miu Double Header
The Testament of Ann Lee actress proves she's the next stylish It-girl to watch.
-
Joy Sunday Has Us Under Her Spell
The Wednesday actress talks season 2, expressing herself through fashion, and living an artist's life.
-
Noah LaLonde Is Back as Our Favorite Brooding Walter Boy
He promises a new and improved Cole for season 2.
-
Every Chic Look Hermione Corfield Wore to Promote the Outlander Prequel
Styled by the iconic Cher Coulter.
-
A New Leading Man Has Entered the Chat
All eyes are on Jamie Roy, star of Outlander: Blood of My Blood.